The standards you keep

Leadership Core Values

Listen instead of read
The short answer

Leadership core values are the small set of standards a founder actually enforces, the ones that decide who you hire, fire, and promote, not the adjectives on the wall. The way Ben Laws frames it with the founders he coaches, you don't invent them in a brainstorm, you excavate them from what you already defend and what you refuse to tolerate. A value only counts if it changes a decision you'd make this week. Done right, real values are what let the business run on a standard instead of on you.

You ran the offsite. You landed on five words, maybe six. Integrity. Excellence. Ownership. They went on the wall, into the deck, onto the careers page. Then Monday happened, and not one person in the building did anything differently because of them.

That's the quiet thing about core values. Most companies have them. Almost none run on them. The words are real. The trouble is they're decoration, and decoration doesn't decide anything.

Why most core values end up as words on a wall

Enron had values. Respect, integrity, communication, excellence, printed right there in its code of ethics while the company was committing one of the largest frauds in history. That's the extreme version of a problem almost every founder has in a milder form: the values on the wall and the behavior in the building have nothing to do with each other.

The reason isn't that founders pick bad words. It's how the words get picked. You sit in a room, you brainstorm what sounds good, you reach for the ones every other company uses, and you walk out with a list that could belong to anyone. A value that could be any company's value isn't yours. It's a logo in word form.

Ben Laws, who coaches founder-operators through exactly this, has a blunt test for it. If the value doesn't change a single decision you'd make this week, it isn't a value yet. It's a wish. And this matters more the bigger you get, because real values are a big part of what lets you get to a business that runs without you. Early on, the standard is whatever you happen to walk past and correct in person. Past a certain size you can't walk past everything, so the values are supposed to do that correcting in your place. If they're just words, nothing does.

Dead values vs. values you run on
Values on the wall
  • Picked in a brainstorm to sound good
  • Written as adjectives (integrity, excellence)
  • Could belong to any company
  • Change no decision you make this week
  • You walk past the behavior that breaks them
Values you run on
  • Excavated from what you defend and refuse
  • Written as behavior you could watch happen
  • Only yours, because they came from you
  • Decide who you hire, fire, and promote
  • Enforced the first time someone crosses them
Same five words. The difference is where they came from and whether you enforce them.

You don't write your core values. You excavate them.

A better brainstorm won't get you there. You have to dig for them instead. Ben's word for the good version of this work is excavating. You're not inventing a set of values to aspire to someday. You're uncovering the ones you already operate by and naming them out loud.

He starts in a place that sounds strange until you try it: annoyance. "What behavior do you find super annoying?" The stuff that tightens your jaw when you see it in the building is a direct readout of what you actually care about. Hate it when someone goes quiet instead of flagging a problem? You value candor. Can't stand watching work ship half-finished? You value craft. Your irritation is honest in a way a brainstorm never is.

Charlotte Grimmel, a performance psychologist who works with founders on building a life around values instead of vanity, made the same point from the other side on the podcast. "Ambition is great, being pulled towards something is great, facing discomfort is great, being in pursuit of something is great. But what are you being ambitious about? That's the selective piece." The pursuit is easy to feel. What you're pursuing it for is the part worth naming, and it's usually already sitting there in what you defend and what you refuse.

The second dig is pride. Ben listens for the moment a founder describes, unprompted, the thing they're proudest of in how their team works. One founder told him he wanted people to feel like family that breaks bread together. Ben stopped him: "You just outlined a manifesto right there." It wasn't on any wall. It was already true. Naming it just made it usable.

How to excavate your real core values
  1. 1
    Run the annoyance auditList the behaviors that set you off when you see them in your company. Each one is a value you're protecting.
  2. 2
    Check what you're proud ofFinish 'I'm proudest of my team when they...' a few times. You're naming values you already live.
  3. 3
    Write it as a behaviorTurn each value from an adjective into something two people could agree they watched happen.
  4. 4
    Point it at a real decisionRun a hire, a fire, or a promotion on your desk this week through the value. Let it make the call.
  5. 5
    Enforce it out loudThe first time someone crosses it, address it. What you tolerate becomes the real list.
You're not inventing values. You're naming the ones you already operate by.

A value you won't enforce isn't a value

One test separates a real value from a nice one: what do you tolerate? You don't learn what a company values by reading the wall. You learn it by watching what gets a pass.

Ben makes founders feel this directly. When one kept skipping the Friday meeting he himself had called non-negotiable, Ben didn't treat it as a calendar problem. "If you're not showing up at a Friday meeting, is that not a reflection of your core values?" Every standard you let slide teaches the team the real list, the one underneath the printed one.

Alex Gertsburg, an attorney and founder who has spent two decades helping companies stay out of court, named what the gap costs on the show. "The disparity between where you are and where your core values are is an energy drain." A value you believe in but don't live doesn't just sit there neutrally. It leaks. Every time you walk past the behavior you said you wouldn't accept, you pay for it, in your own energy and in what the team now believes you actually mean.

Write them as behavior, not adjectives

"Integrity" tells no one what to do. Every company on earth would claim it, which is the proof that on its own it's empty. A value only gets real when you write it as something a person does, stated clearly enough that two people would agree on whether it happened.

Ben Utecht, who won a Super Bowl with the Colts and now helps founders turn values into a working system, makes this his whole discipline. He won't let a company leave its values as a few words on an About page. He turns them into what he calls a Culture Creed, a written document spelling out the specific behavior each value looks like on a normal Tuesday, so it can be taught and onboarded instead of just admired.

Ben Laws pushes the same point in coaching with one question: is it written down? "Is everything you just articulated actually written out? It should be written out." A value that lives only in your head stays yours alone. A value written as observable behavior can belong to the whole company.

Your core values are a hiring, firing, and promotion filter

You find out whether a company really holds a value by looking at who it rewards. Values earn their keep in three decisions: who you hire, who you let go, and who you promote. If your stated value is ownership but the person who dodges accountability keeps getting promoted because they hit their number, then the real value is the number, and everyone can see it.

This is the version of core values that does actual work instead of sitting on a wall. Run every hire against them. Make them a line in the promotion conversation. And the hard one: be willing to let a talented person go when they win in a way that violates them, because the day you keep that person is the day the value becomes optional for everyone watching.

What your values are actually worth

Two payoffs make this worth a founder's Saturday. The first is who you become. Ben frames core values as less of a company exercise than it looks: "these are core values for a company because we believe that this creates in you... who you are and who you are being and becoming is going to show up differently." The standards you actually hold shape the person running the business, not just the business.

The second is money, and it's the one exit-minded owners miss. Ben Utecht put it in deal terms: "The number one reason M&A fails is culture. So if culture can add enterprise value, you've just de-risked the acquisition." Values that are real, written, and lived are what let a company hold its performance after the founder steps back. That's exactly what a buyer pays for, and what a successor has to inherit. Fuzzy values are a key-man risk wearing nicer clothes.

This is the work Ben does with founders week after week, turning a wall of adjectives into a set of standards the business actually runs on. If your values look good on the careers page but don't decide anything, that's worth a real conversation.

How to define your core values this week

Start with the annoyance audit. Write down the three behaviors that most reliably set you off when you see them in your company. Flip each one into the value it's protecting. Then do the pride version: finish the sentence "I'm proudest of my team when they..." two or three times. You'll have more raw material than you expected, because you've been living these the whole time.

Then make one of them real. Write it as a behavior, not an adjective. Point it at one decision already on your desk this week, a hire, a fire, or a promotion, and let the value make the call. That's the whole difference between values you have and values you run on.

Once the values are real, how you build a team culture around them is the next question, and leading as yourself instead of a role is what keeps them from feeling corporate.

What to actually do

Most values are decoration

Almost every company has core values. Almost none run on them. If the words on the wall don't change a decision you'd make this week, they're a wish, not a value.

You excavate values, you don't invent them

The good values are already in you. Ben's annoyance audit ('what behavior do you find super annoying?') and the pride test pull them out faster than any brainstorm.

What you tolerate is the real list

A value you won't enforce isn't a value. Every standard you let slide teaches the team the list underneath the printed one, and the gap drains your energy.

Write behavior, not adjectives

'Integrity' tells no one what to do. A value only gets real when you write it as something a person does, clearly enough that two people agree on whether it happened.

Values live in hiring, firing, and promotion

You find out what a company really values by who it rewards. Run every hire, fire, and promotion through the values or they stay decoration.

Real values add enterprise value

Lived values are what let a business hold its performance after the founder steps back. That's what a buyer pays for and a successor inherits. Fuzzy values are a key-man risk in nicer clothes.

From the podcast

“Ambition is great, being pulled towards something is great, facing discomfort is great, being in pursuit of something is great. But what are you being ambitious about? That's the selective piece.”
Charlotte Grimmel, performance psychologist and founder of The Mind Friend · Watch the episode
“The disparity between where you are and where your core values are is an energy drain.”
Alex Gertsburg, attorney and founder of Cover My Six · Watch the episode
“The number one reason M&A fails is culture. So if culture can add enterprise value, you've just de-risked the acquisition.”
Ben Utecht, Super Bowl champion and culture strategist, author of The Champion's Creed · Watch the episode

Common questions

What are leadership core values?
They're the small set of standards a leader actually enforces, the ones that decide who gets hired, promoted, and let go. Real core values aren't the adjectives on a wall; they're the behaviors you defend and the ones you refuse to tolerate. A value only counts if it changes a decision you'd make this week.
How do I figure out my company's core values?
Stop brainstorming and start excavating. Run an annoyance audit: the behaviors that reliably set you off when you see them in your company point straight at what you value. Then finish the sentence 'I'm proudest of my team when they...' a few times. You've been living your real values the whole time; the work is naming them, not inventing them.
Why don't our core values change how anyone behaves?
Usually because they were picked to sound good, written as vague adjectives, and never enforced. A value you walk past when someone breaks it isn't a value to your team, it's a suggestion. People learn what you actually value by watching what gets a pass, not by reading the wall.
How do I write core values that stick?
Write each one as a behavior, not an adjective, clearly enough that two people would agree on whether it happened. Then point it at real decisions: run every hire, promotion, and exit through it. Ben Utecht turns values into a written Culture Creed so each one spells out what it looks like on a normal day, which is what makes them teachable instead of decorative.
How many core values should a business have?
Few enough that you can actually enforce every one. Three to five is plenty. A long list is a tell that they were brainstormed rather than lived, and the more you have, the more of them you'll quietly let slide, which teaches the team that the whole list is optional.
Do core values really affect what a business is worth?
Yes. Lived values are what let a company hold its performance after the founder steps back, and that's exactly what a buyer or a successor is paying for. As Ben Utecht notes, culture is the number one reason acquisitions fail, so real values de-risk an exit. Fuzzy ones are a key-man risk in nicer clothes.

Do your values decide anything, or just sit on the wall?

This is the work Ben does with founder-operators every week. Not another brainstorm, but excavating the standards you already run by, writing them as behavior, and pointing them at the hires, fires, and promotions that prove what you actually value. If the business is supposed to run on a standard instead of on you, let's talk.

Work with Ben

Keep going